The Plains of Troy

Carl Phillips

It is Odysseus who, having seen his rival Ajax brought down

by madness, equates a life on earth with nothing—all of it

illusion. The Greek camp lies rippling in front of him

with the latest slaughter, with a seeming addiction to rank,

stamina, the cleanest distance from shame possible, and

to a longing that at once is sexual and somewhere also

has to do with war as the context without which                                                              

                                                                                      value’s shape

becomes barely discernible. Three horses turn softly,

simultaneous, in the wind’s direction. A series of veils—

raised, and unraised: is this what it comes to, the examined life?

Must it? The drive toward meaning not, in fact, in the face of

meaninglessness, but of irrelevance—to have meant,

without mattering finally—that more palpable darkness,

magisterially unfurling its wings, then folding them equally around

the sleepers, the awake and restless, the freshly raped, the slain?


The Yale Review is committed to publishing pieces from its archive as they originally appeared, without alterations to spelling, content, or style. Occasionally, errors creep in due to the digitization process; we work to correct these errors as we find them. You can email [email protected] with any you find.

Carl Phillips is the author of seventeen collections of poetry, including Scattered Snows, to the North. In 2023, his book Then the War: And Selected Poems 2007–2020 won the Pulitzer Prize.
Originally published:
April 1, 2008

Featured

Searching for Seamus Heaney

What I found when I resolved to read him
Elisa Gonzalez

What Happened When I Began to Speak Welsh

By learning my family's language, I hoped to join their conversation.
Dan Fox

When Does a Divorce Begin?

Most people think of it as failure. For me it was an achievement.
Anahid Nersessian

You Might Also Like

Community

Finding company on and off the page
Carl Phillips



Support Our Writers

A sustaining subscription provides vital, ongoing support for The Yale Review and the writers we publish—and includes new holiday merch.
Become a Sustaining Subscriber